Two outdoor theatre performances are planned for the same afternoon. Before the day begins, the weather is either calm (60% probability) or stormy (40%). Given calm weather, each performance runs with probability 90%; given stormy weather, each runs with probability 30%. Once the day's weather category is fixed, the two performances' remaining operational outcomes are independent.
What is the probability that both performances go ahead? What is the chance that either particular performance runs? Are the two run-or-cancel indicators independent before the weather is known? A planner wants to multiply the two headline success probabilities; show precisely what that calculation gets wrong.
Get hint
Hint 1
Separate the calm and stormy possibilities first. You may multiply the two performance probabilities only after conditioning on weather.
Show solution
Let \(A\) and \(B\) mean that the respective performances run, and let \(W\) denote the shared weather condition. Conditioning on the common cause and using the stipulated conditional independence,
\(\Pr(A\cap B)=0.6(0.9)(0.9)+0.4(0.3)(0.3)=0.486+0.036=\boxed{0.522}\).
Either performance separately runs with probability \(\Pr(A)=\Pr(B)=0.6(0.9)+0.4(0.3)=0.54+0.12=\boxed{0.66}\). If they were independent without conditioning, the joint probability would be \(0.66^2=0.4356\), which is not \(0.522\); the difference, \(0.0864\), is their covariance as binary indicators. Shared good-weather days boost both events simultaneously, while shared bad-weather days suppress both.
As a full-table check, the probabilities of (both run, only A runs, only B runs, neither runs) are \((0.522,0.138,0.138,0.202)\). They are nonnegative, sum to one, and each performance's marginal success probability is \(0.522+0.138=0.66\). Conditional independence within weather categories does not imply unconditional independence after mixing over weather.
Assumptions
The two performances experience the same weather category; their operational outcomes are independent given that category.
The reported run probabilities apply identically to both performances within each weather category.
Final Answer
Each performance runs with probability 0.66; both run with probability 0.522, not \(0.66^2=0.4356\). The indicators are unconditionally dependent.