Question
A conservator moves two specimen jars, chosen uniformly at random without replacement, from cupboard A into cupboard B. Before the move, A contains three jars marked fragile and three unmarked jars; B contains two fragile and four unmarked jars.
An assistant watching the move reports only that at least one of the two transferred jars was fragile. The conservator cannot see which jars were moved. Two jars are then selected uniformly without replacement from the now-enlarged cupboard B.
Given the assistant's report, what is the probability that both inspected jars are fragile?
Get hint
Hint 1
Let \(K\) be the number of fragile jars transferred. The report rules out \(K=0\), but it does not tell you whether \(K=1\) or \(K=2\).
Check your answer
Solution
A transfer is an equally likely two-jar subset of A. There are \(\binom62=15\) such subsets, of which
\[ P(K=0)=\frac{\binom32}{15}=\frac15,\qquad P(K=1)=\frac{\binom31\binom31}{15}=\frac35,\qquad P(K=2)=\frac{\binom32}{15}=\frac15. \]
The report is \(R=\{K\ge1\}\), with probability \(4/5\). Bayes conditioning gives \(P(K=1\mid R)=3/4\) and \(P(K=2\mid R)=1/4\). When \(K=k\), the enlarged cupboard B has \(8\) jars, exactly \(2+k\) of them fragile. Drawing two without replacement has conditional probability
\[ P(\text{two fragile}\mid K=k)=\frac{\binom{2+k}{2}}{\binom82}. \]
Thus the required mixture is
\[ \frac34\frac{\binom32}{\binom82}+\frac14\frac{\binom42}{\binom82} =\frac34\frac3{28}+\frac14\frac6{28}=\boxed{\frac{15}{112}}. \]
An exact enumeration confirms the result: among the 12 transferable pairs satisfying the report, nine contain one fragile jar and three contain two. Each leads to 28 equally likely inspection pairs, with respectively three and six favourable ones. Therefore the answer is \((9\cdot3+3\cdot6)/(12\cdot28)=45/336=15/112\). Treating the two inspected jars as independent or replacing the hidden transfer by its average composition would give the wrong model.
Assumptions
Within each cupboard, all subsets of a given sampled size are equally likely.
Transfer and inspection are performed without replacement as stated.
The only transfer information disclosed is the event that at least one moved jar was fragile; the full composition remains hidden.
Final Answer
\(15/112\), approximately \(13.39\%\).