Question
At a science exhibit, two lights are controlled by a single fresh random number U drawn uniformly from 0 to 1. The blue light switches on when \(U<0.30\), and the amber light switches on when \(U<0.70\). A new U is drawn only for the next show: during one show the lights always use the same number.
What is the probability that both lights switch on? Also list the possible on/off combinations with their probabilities. Would you get the correct answer by multiplying the two individual activation probabilities?
Get hint
Hint 1
If the blue light is on, what must be true of the amber light?
Check your answer
Solution
Let \(B=\{U<0.30\}\) and \(A=\{U<0.70\}\). Because \(0.30<0.70\), B is a subset of A. Thus \(\Pr(B\cap A)=\Pr(B)=0.30\), not \(\Pr(B)\Pr(A)=0.21\).
On \(0\le U<0.30\), both lights are on, probability 0.30. On \(0.30\le U<0.70\), blue is off and amber is on, probability 0.40. On \(0.70\le U\le1\), both are off, probability 0.30. Blue on with amber off is impossible, probability zero. These four probabilities sum to one.
The product rule \(\Pr(B\cap A)=\Pr(B)\Pr(A)\) would require independence, which is contradicted by the deterministic inclusion \(B\subset A\). For instance \(\Pr(A\mid B)=1\) whereas \(\Pr(A)=0.70\).
Assumptions
U is a continuously uniform random draw on \([0,1]\).
The same U controls both thresholds for a given exhibit show.
Final Answer
\(\Pr(\text{both on})=0.30\). The (blue,amber) outcomes are (on,on): 0.30, (off,on): 0.40, (off,off): 0.30, and (on,off): 0. Multiplying \(0.30\times0.70\) is incorrect.