Question
A race steward knows whether two kinds of incident occurred: a false start (F) and an equipment fault (E). Each independently occurs with probability 1/2 during a race.
The steward's public bulletin is limited to one line. If neither occurs, it says “No incident.” If only one occurs, it names that one. If both occur, the steward reports “False start” with probability 3/4 and “Equipment fault” with probability 1/4, using an independent random choice. Nothing in the bulletin says whether the other incident also happened.
After seeing the bulletin “False start,” what is the probability that an equipment fault also occurred?
Get hint
Hint 1
A false-start-only race always produces “False start,” but a race with both incidents does so only three-quarters of the time.
Check your answer
Solution
Independence and the two 1/2 incident probabilities give four underlying states, each with probability 1/4: neither, F only, E only, and both.
The bulletin “False start” is produced with probability 1 in the F-only state and with probability 3/4 in the both-incidents state. Hence
\(\Pr(\text{bulletin F})=(\frac14)\cdot1+(\frac14)\cdot(\frac34)=\frac14+\frac3{16}=\)\(\frac7{16}\).
For E to have occurred on a race with that bulletin, the underlying state must be both incidents. Its joint probability with bulletin F is \((\frac14)(\frac34)=\frac3{16}\). Thus
\(\Pr(E\text{ occurred}\mid\text{bulletin F})=\frac{3/16}{7/16}=\)\(\frac37\).
As a consistency check, the equipment-fault bulletin has probability \(\frac14+(\frac14)(\frac14)=\frac5{16}\), and “No incident” occurs with probability \(\frac4{16}\). These add to \(\frac7{16}+\frac5{16}+\frac4{16}=1\). The observed line is evidence not only about which incidents are possible, but also about which line the steward preferentially selects when both are present.
Assumptions
The false start and equipment fault occur independently, each with probability 1/2.
The steward observes the true pair of incidents and follows the specified random reporting rule without error.
The 3/4 versus 1/4 choice when both occur is independent of everything else.
Final Answer
\(\frac37\approx42.857\%\).